Homemade Mod Podge Recipe — DIY Vs. Store-Bought!

If you’ve ever wondered whether homemade Mod Podge really compares to the store-bought version, this tutorial is for you!

I tested them side by side to see how they perform on real craft projects, everything from texture and clarity to durability and finish.

You’ll see exactly which one came out on top (and how much money you can save making your own!).

🎥 Watch the full video for complete instructions!

In my video, I walk you through the exact recipe, mixing ratios, and side-by-side comparison between homemade and store-bought Mod Podge. You’ll see how each version performs on real projects and which one gives the best results.

Homemade Mod Podge (Matte Finish):

Elmer’s School Glue (or any white PVA glue)

Water

Small airtight jar or container (Dollar Store or reuse old jars)

Spoon or stir stick for mixing

Homemade Mod Podge (Glossy or Satin Finish):

Elmer’s School Glue

Water

Polycrylic Sealer (satin or gloss, depending on preference)

Small airtight jar or container

Measuring cups (½ cup, ¼ cup)

Tablespoon

Paper towel or cloth (to keep workspace clean)

Optional funnel or spouted cup (for easier pouring)

Combine white glue and water

Shake or stir well until completely blended.

For a glossy or satin finish, add a small amount of polycrylic sealer to your mixture.

Use your homemade Mod Podge on paper, fabric, or simple craft projects.

It works beautifully for basic decoupage and kids’ crafts but if you want professional, long-lasting results or need to do image transfers, store-bought Mod Podge still gives the best finish.